The Old Sheriff's House in Crown Point, Indiana which oversees the Lake County Jail, where John Dillinger escaped in 1934

A Surprising Destination: Northwest Indiana’s South Shore

Some posts on this site contain affiliate links, meaning if you book or buy something through one of these links, we may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you).

“The Portal to Hell, Gary Indiana.” That was a caption under a photo in an article I was reading one night describing Gary, Indiana. I’ve been to some pretty rough places over the years and thought there’s no way in the world that Gary can be THAT bad. So I decided to see for myself and discovered a region shaking off its past reputation while looking to the future. It’s safe to say, my visit to Northwest Indiana and the South Shore absolutely surprised me!

Sign saying "The People of Gary Welcome You."
I felt encouraged to visit Gary

I had a lot of people ask me “Why on earth would you go to Northwest Indiana?” The city of Gary developed a notorious reputation as the “murder capital of America” for many years in the 1990s and a city that’s been in decline for decades, losing over 50% of the city residents to neighboring South Shore towns. And, thanks to Michael Moore, the world thinks of the region as a smelly, industrial wasteland.

I’m not going to say everyone has got it all wrong and it is some kind of tropical paradise. Yes, the city of Gary itself is still struggling, but I think the region’s hardened image was earned years ago and isn’t reflective of the rebirth that’s happening today. There are some great things to do in Northwest Indiana!

Top Things To Do in Northwest Indiana

UFO car driving on the highway in Northern Indiana
Spied aliens on the highway

The Gary SouthShore RailCats

Right in the heart of downtown Gary, the local boys of summer take the field as part of the American Association of Independent Professional Baseball (not affiliated with the MLB). The stadium, U.S. Steel Yard, is a very intimate venue and there isn’t a bad seat in the house. The Gary SouthShore RailCats were the 2013 league champions and play some fine baseball.

I caught a RailCats game when the Winnipeg Goldeyes came to town. The RailCats struck early on a Goldeyes error, but ended up losing the hard fought 6-5 game. This is serious baseball and it doesn’t get any more exciting or authentic!

The Gary South Shore RailCats at the U.S. Steel Stadium, one of the great things to do in Gary Indiana
The RailCats playing at U.S. Steel Stadium in Gary

The Jackson Home

Gary, Indiana’s favorite son is Michael Jackson. All of the Jackson clan lived at 2300 Jackson Street in Gary, Indiana and this modest home is where The Jackson 5 got their start. Today, the Jackson home is a private residence with a large security fence, but a monument to Michael Jackson stands in the front yard.

Each day, a steady stream of visitors arrives to pay homage to the King of Pop and The Jackson 5. Given how Michael Jackson’s life ended, the house could take on a circus-like ambiance, but it really isn’t like that. The visitors to the Jackson house are looking for more than a cultural oddity; they want to connect to the man who altered music forever.

Michael Jackson monument in front of the Jackson Family home in Gary
Michael Jackson’s boyhood home at 2300 Jackson Street

Pierogi Fest

Release your inner Slav and embrace all things Eastern European at the Pierogi Fest in Whiting, Indiana. The Pierogi Fest is an institution and has been featured everywhere from Oprah to the Food Network. This is the perfect opportunity to enjoy a pierogi, have a beer and maybe sample the kielbasa with sauerkraut.

Originally a food festival, it has turned into the classic summer festival complete with crafts, music, competitions and a “dunk a nun” tank. You’re guaranteed two things at Pierogi Fest: you’ll have a great time and you won’t leave hungry.

The street during the annual Pierogi Fest in Whiting, one of the top things to do in NWI
Pierogi Fest in Whiting

South Shore Brewery Trail

Northwest Indiana is in the midst of a craft beer renaissance. The region has 17 craft breweries and microbreweries producing a wide range of fine stouts and ales. Brewers in Northwest Indiana have embraced the terroir of Lake Michigan water and white wheat grain. But beer lovers expecting only Pils and Hefeweizen can take heart that the region produces a slew of explosive hop-heavy, West Coast-style IPAs and other ingenious brews.

Two notable breweries on the South Shore are the Crown Brewery in Crown Point and Figure Eight Brewing in Valparaiso. Any visitor to Northwest Indiana could easily spend a weekend on the South Shore Brewery Trail.

Oak barrels in the Beer Vault at Crown Brewery
The Beer Vault at Crown Brewery in Crown Point

Fair Oaks Farms Adventure Center

There’s a lot of farmland in Northwest Indiana and Fair Oaks Farms makes the farming accessible to city folk. Fair Oaks is a 40,000 acre working dairy farm with over 40,000 head. I was able to get a behind-the-scenes tour of the sprawling two-acre vegetable garden which feeds the 280-seat Farmhouse restaurant – this takes farm-to-table to a new level (total distance from the two-acre garden to the restaurant is about 600 yards).

I was able to get a sneak peak of the future of Fair Oaks Farms: a 8,600 tree pick-your-own-fruit orchard. But the highlights for the kids are The Dairy Adventure and The Pig Adventure – a unique view into the world of a commercial farming operation. If you’re looking for things to do in Northwest Indiana with kids, there’s something here for kids of all ages (and the young at heart).

Cows on the Dairy-Go-Round at Fair Oaks Farms Adventure Center in Northern Indiana
The “Dairy-Go-Round” at Fair Oaks Farms

Northwest Indiana Wineries

A half-dozen wineries have established themselves in the area, just across the state line from the Lake Michigan Shore AVA. The wines range from light fruity and Frontenac’s at Anderson Winery to complicated blends at Shady Creek Winery. The R.D.R. red blend at Shady Creek is one of the best wines I’ve had in a long time – a medium bodied Bordeaux-blend featuring Merlot grapes from Michigan giving a slightly smoky nose and strong hints of black cherry. I could drink that all day long!

Bottle and wine glass at Shady Creek Winery
Wine Tasting Shady Creek Winery

The Old Sheriffs House and the Lake County Jail

Sitting in the Crown Point Brewery drinking a mellow Industrial Porter and eating a slice of chunky sausage pizza from Carriage Court Pizza, I was about to embark on a remarkable journey! The owners (Fred Laud and Steve Mazylewski) were telling me the story of opening the brewery and pizza parlor, when they inadvertently let slip that we were sitting in the midst of a historical complex. In fact, one of America’s most infamous events occurred right on that spot! They had my attention.

Historical marker sign for Lake County Sheriff's House and Jail

The Crown Point Brewery/Carriage Court Pizza are in the power plant and inmate booking room of the Lake County Jail. The two-story Old Sheriff’s House is located on Main Street with the large three-story Lake County Jail extending off the back.

Evidently, in 1926, the sheriff wanted to be close to the inmates and it she (yes, the sheriff was a woman who took over the role after her husband was killed in the line of duty) claimed it was “escape proof.” That was proven factually incorrect when John Dillinger escaped on March 3, 1934 using a piece of carved wood for a gun (according to legend).

Unfortunately, the site is infrequently open to the public, so I wasn’t able to go in. However, I was able to get into the arraignment room in the building just across the alley (it’s now used as a reception hall for weddings) and see where Dillinger was arraigned and his lawyer lobbied to keep him the Lake County Jail. This whole episode is portrayed in the movie Public Enemies.

Mural in the courtroom of the Hall of Justice in Crown Point
Mural in the courtroom where John Dillinger was arraigned

Those who told me not to visit the South Shore obviously hadn’t been there in a long time. This was hardly the “Portal to Hell” rumored on the Internet. Quite the opposite, I found the people in Northwest Indiana to be humble, hard-working folks who genuinely cared whether I was having a good time. They showed me there are many interesting things to do in Northwest Indiana.

The Albanese Candy Factory and Outlet Store
A sweet finish

Northwest Indiana Visitor Information

The Gary SouthShore RailCats, One Stadium Plaza, Gary, IN 46402. Season runs mid-May to early-September (plus post-season opportunities).

The Jackson Home, 2300 Jackson Street, Gary, IN 46407. The home can be visited at any time, but not recommended after dark.

Crown Point Brewery / Carriage Court Pizza, 211 S East St., Crown Point, IN 46307.

Figure Eight Brewing, 150 S. Washington St., Valparaiso, IN 46383.

Fair Oaks Farms Adventure Center, 856 N 600 E, Fair Oaks, IN 47943.

Anderson’s Winery, Inc., 430 E. US-6, Valparaiso, IN 46383. I found Anderson’s randomly closed, so check before going.

Shady Creek Winery, 2030 Tryon Rd., Michigan City, IN 46360.

The Old Sheriffs House and the Lake County Jail, 226 South Main St., Crown Point, IN 46307.

Other activities in NWI on the South Shore: visiting one of the lakefront casinos, exploring the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and Indiana Dunes State Park, or seeing the “A Christmas Story” Comes Home exhibit around the holidays.

The barn at the Fair Oaks Farms Adventure Center
The barn at Fair Oaks Farms

Special thanks to my hosts at the South Shore CVA for their hospitality and for showing me a great time.

And because you can have never have enough photos:

I Polka on the First Date! t-shirt
Sign for the Hall of Justice in Crown Point, Indiana
The Hall of Justice where John Dillinger was arraigned
Kielbasa sausage on the grill at Pierogi Fest
Experiencing the Kielbasa – I love a good sausage
Pierogies at Pierogi Fest in Whiting
The World Famous Pierogies

6 thoughts on “A Surprising Destination: Northwest Indiana’s South Shore”

  1. Wow, I had no idea about northwest Indiana! Thanks for the great tips. I was sold at the farm adventure and restaurant, and the wineries are just a bonus!

  2. The Fairoaks farm is getting bigger their hotel is almost ready! And it’s a shame you missed so much in Northwest Indiana visit again and hit the beach after going to Michigan city zoo, and the shopping oh my! Really come back!

  3. So excited that you mentioned Crown Point! I grew up there, my grandparents got married in the as we referred to it when we were kids, the red courthouse. Which has a beautiful room upstairs made of marble and in the basement are shops. And Carriage Court Pizza was very close to my house. Great food! I don’t live there anymore, but I wanted to say thank you for sharing!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.